Bangkok-Chon Buri plan ‘flawed’, expert says – Calls for revamp of new motorway blueprint
17 September 2018
The Ministry of Transport should revise the design of the elevated six-lane road on the Bangkok-Chon Buri motorway to reduce costs, construction time, pollution and land expropriation, an academic at King Mongkut’s Institute of Technology Ladkrabang (KMITL) says.
Associate Professor Supot Srinil, deputy rector of KMITL, said he accepted that the project needs to be built to reduce traffic congestion.
Yet he said the government should conduct more studies “because there are flaws in the design blueprint” of the eastern inter-provincial motorway project.
The primary worry concerns pillars to be erected along this eastern inter-provincial motorway, which will cost 35 billion baht to build.
Under the current design, two elevated roads are planned — for inbound and outbound lanes, separately. That would require the state developer to pay for more pillars, more land expropriation on roadsides and will need more time to build.
But the construction time can be shortened to 700 days instead of over 1,000 days and costs brought down to 20 billion baht if the blueprint is revised, said Assc Prof Supot, who is an expert in civil engineering and environmental management.
He said current technology allows engineers to do this, citing the elevated Bhuraphawithi Expressway which is built above the median traffic strip along a 55-km section of Bang Na-Trat road.
The single pillars not only enable the government to speed up construction by 36% and save the budget by 37% in this project, but they also require less space, during and after construction, Mr Supot said.
This will help the government avoid being dragged into environmental problems and land expropriation issues.
Assc Prof Supot cautioned that under the current plan, the contractor needs to place pillars on both roadsides.
As a result, officials need to claim some adjacent areas for the construction.
He said the pillar design would affect property values along both sides of the road. ”The project should not cause an impact on roadside areas,” he said.
The government needs to look into the future in which the land can serve as new business, university and community areas, he said.
In terms of the environment, the two-pillar design will make the elevated road stand closer to existing communities.
Old car engines can emit ultra-fine dust particles, known as particulate matter (PM) 2.5, into the air and pose a health risk because its size of less than 2.5 micrometres, which is smaller than the width of a human hair, can easily lodge into lungs.
Noise pollution is also a matter of concern, he added. According to the blueprint of the project, soundproof walls will be added only near educational and religious compounds. “These may not be enough to deal with the unpleasant noise.”
The Transport Ministry already held public hearings on the project and is looking forward to the construction.
Officials expect the new elevated motorway will serve up to 150,000 cars a day.
Officials are planning to build the new 18.5-kilometre road from Srinakarin interchange to Thap Yao in Bangkok’s Lat Krabang district as an alternate and “faster” route for drivers.
The eastern inter-provincial motorway is a key transport link between Bangkok and Chon Buri, one of three provinces in the Eastern Economic Corridor (EEC), in Rayong and Chachoengsao. The inter-provincial motorway will serve as transport link to EEC.
The construction, set to start next year, is expected to take 1,095 days to complete in 2022.
Mr Supot raised concern that the 35-billion baht project might not be able to relieve traffic congestion as expected.